If he's not getting what he needs at school and you can give it to him, then yes! It's a great reason!

I don't mean to sound like a homeschooling pusher. I'm not one, really. (See my cautious reply above to Montana for evidence.)

It's just that it is so clear that your DS's problems are school-related, and the school has been so negative about it all. I kind of think the same thing about your situation that I thought about ours: what have you got to lose by trying it? Worst case, you put him back in, right? Or is there some risk to removing him that I'm not considering?

P.S. I'm glad I made you smile. You need more of that! smile

Kriston