Gifted Issues Discussion homepage Forums Learning Environments Middle school choices

FWIW, I have talked to a few families with gifted kids who have really thrived in the expeditionary learning model. In these families, the kids struggled to fit in the traditional school model and their kids seemed to be divergent thinkers.

From what you have said, your dd has struggled on the traditional path. I would let her try the alternative school. You always can supplement math at home using something like ALEKS. I think that its worth a try before resorting to homeschooling an extrovert.