Originally Posted by ABQMom
We spent a half hour with all but one complaining about his work ethic, his laziness, his inability to turn things in or find work, the unwillingness to treat them with the respect they deserved, and his inappropriate comments that made the rest of the class laugh or misdirected the lesson into something that didn't matter. My kiddo listened to all of it, challenged a couple of the complaints and ended up being right, and actually apologized when he discovered that something he'd done had hurt a teacher's feelings when he had no idea that is how she felt.

When one of the teachers told him that he was in danger of failing 8th grade, my kid told them, "No, I'm not. This is a social promotion state, and you'd have to get my parents to sign off on me being held back. And they're not going to hold me back because of some zeros because I haven't had the right support here."

It lasted three hours, but the one silver lining is that the counselor and special ed chair for high school didn't seem tainted by the attitudes in the room and said they thought he'd find a much better fit in high school. They said they'd work to place him with teachers that they thought would be open to a more independent approach to learning and a more creative process for completing work.

I've tasted of false hope before, though, so I know how crushing it can be to believe the promise and then it not be any different. But I'm hoping it will be better. I do know that I won't let them drag me in like this in high school. I can't survive it.
Good for him. That is wonderful he can advocate for himself.

Last year when my husband & I were advocating for my son to be admitted to H. Biology rather than Earth Science this year. My son didn't want to push, didn't want to rock the boat but we both knew that pushing the school was the right thing. He received 99% on the tests in 8th grade science, but was not filling in the seatwork/homework completely. One question missing on a page, gave you a zero for the whole thing. His teacher didn't think he had the study skills for honors level science.

H. Biology this year is wonderful. The students read the book (a significantly harder book), listen to lectures, take tests and do labs and write them up. There are no worksheets to fill out, most of the grade is the test. He is so much happier and it's his best class.

I hope you son had better luck in H.S.