Is it accurate that she is at a gifted magnet and is being subject-accelerated for some subjects? If so, I don't believe I would advocate for a skip. Of course, you have much more knowledge than I do. Although my DS is a very good candidate for a skip, I don't know that we'll do it because I expect him to join DD's gifted magnet is grade 2 and I know the expectations for workload are not going to be age-appropriate if he skips (regardless of ability, which would not be an issue, IMO). I think it will be a "close enough" fit once he gets there, as it has been for DD, though I'm quite concerned about K and 1. Obviously, magnets vary. DD's is pretty good.