|
0 members (),
648
guests, and
45
robots. |
|
Key:
Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod
|
|
|
S |
M |
T |
W |
T |
F |
S |
|
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
|
5
|
6
|
7
|
|
8
|
9
|
10
|
11
|
12
|
13
|
14
|
|
15
|
16
|
17
|
18
|
19
|
20
|
21
|
|
22
|
23
|
24
|
25
|
26
|
27
|
28
|
|
29
|
30
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Re: Quotations that resonate with gifted people
Eagle Mum
11/15/26 12:25 AM
You are right. The Beatitudes describe the steps of spiritual growth and their outcomes. It’s my favourite part of the Bible.
Just because we have a little superficial knowledge on how some things work, doesn’t mean we truly understand the intricacies of the universe. I suspect we all have a tendency to similar misconceptions as the builders of the Tower of Babel.
124
704,788
Read More
|
|
Re: Help understanding my child!
moonpie
11/10/26 01:32 AM
A bit of an update now she’s 13.
Her school achievement has evened out overall but I still have a sense of disconnect between capacity and achievement. She still flies under the radar as a quiet, reserved kid at school.
She ended up accessing excellent enrichment through the latter half of primary.
We recently needed updated testing for access to enrichment at a new secondary school.
She did the 10 subtests of WISC V with an excellent psych. Her results are a bit different to when she was younger, although strengths and relative weaknesses are similar.
Her VCI has jumped to 142 (Voc 17, Sim 18). Her FRI is slightly higher at 123, but she was frustrated by time limits on FW. She was also frustrated by time limits on BD. Her WMI and VSI were around 115. Her PSI was 103. She got a GAI at the 99pc and I am fairly confident she qualifies for enrichment.
Talking to her, she found time limits really annoying. I know she can work extremely quickly when motivated and engaged. I don’t really know what to make of the PSI and whether there’s an element of won’t rather than can’t! (Incidentally she’s left handed).
I would love thoughts on the best ways to support her learning, although she’s doing pretty well now and is generally a happy, well-rounded kid.
7
7,087
Read More
|
|
Re: What exactly counts as prepping?
aeh
11/07/26 10:54 PM
So.. more than one perspective on this:
1. The publisher explicitly describes the series as test prep for cognitive assessments including the Wechslers, Stanford-Binets and all of the major GT assessments most commonly used by school districts and private schools. So from that point of view, yes, it is definitively test prepping, and competitive-entry private schools have a right to exclude them--but I think enforcement that de-activates an application should fairly be invoked only if it is clearly well-understood by the application population well in advance that this is not allowed. I am assuming that in LLL's community this is clearly understood.
but,
2. If the sample pages for the beginner 1/2 books are representative of the activities in them, then most of them are within the realm of a high-quality preschool or kindergarten curriculum, with the exception of the figural series--which the publisher even goes so far as to point out are similar to the CogAT, etc. I wouldn't even worry about the attribute blocks. The blocks I saw on the publisher's site were pretty typical of preschool educational materials (shapes and colors). And the connecting blocks are just the classic unifix cubes. I expect I still have a bunch of similar blocks lying around my house that I bought off Amazon or at the dollar store. (Although since my children are all well beyond that developmental stage, I should probably give them to someone who will use them!) Now if you had Wechsler blocks like the ones used during testing, or something similar, that would be a significant problem. (...and I have those too...but my kids aren't playing with them!)
FWIW, the sample pages from the next levels up (grade school) skate substantially closer to violating intellectual property laws for major cognitive tests. Those are clearly test prepping.
IOW, technically, yes, it is test prepping, but no, I don't think I would have DQ'd your child's scores either. And to the more important question about educational fit, no, I would not worry that he will be misplaced if he attends the local GT school. It is unlikely the question of fit will hinge on a few points one way or the other on the WPPSI.
And remember, (and this goes for any school and many other parenting decisions) even if it does turn out to be a poor fit for him, you can always change, even in the middle of the year. Don't ever feel like you are locked into a specific pathway for yourself or your children, especially at the expense of the health (physical, mental, etc.) of your child, yourself and your family.
3
785
Read More
|
|
Re: What exactly counts as prepping?
lululo4321
11/05/26 02:56 AM
Where we live, it would absolutely be considered test prep for WPPSI and if you were applying to one of the top private schools, the testing center would report the prep to the schools, and your child's application would no longer be active. Now, that wasn't your question, so I'll let the experts respond.
3
785
Read More
|
|
Questions about my Kindergartener
L Mom
11/04/26 07:59 PM
I wasn't sure how to title this because I have a variety of concerns regarding my Kindergartener. I'll try to keep it as short as I can.
He is 5 with a spring birthday. We had him evaluated at age 4 due to his preschool teacher commenting that it might be worthwhile to have him do an extra year of preschool before kindergarten (very common in our area, almost a default for spring and summer kids). I didn't feel this was appropriate because he was already reading pretty well and understanding math beyond kindergarten level. We sought the evaluation to help with our decision making process and also some concerns about extreme shyness. I sat in on testing and felt he was very quick to say "I don't know" instead of attempting questions. He did not score in the gifted range on the wppsi-iv.
The psychologist agreed with us that he was very ready for kindergarten, so we ended up sending him to kindergarten this year. For reference, he is in a private school which performs similarly to the better public schools in our area on standardized testing. There isn't any specific gifted or advanced programming, but we were told that there would be small group instruction at each child's level after beginning of the year testing. He tested at the 99th percentile in reading and math. He has a first year teacher, and she did not get small groups going as early as we were told. We also found out that she is only planning to do small groups once a week, and that none of the other kids are working at a level similar to our son, so he will still be working on things that are very easy for him.
I worry a lot about him not having any work at his actual level. That's how it was for me all throughout school, and it was an adjustment to learn how to study and make real effort in graduate school. I really don't know what to do to advocate for him. On one hand, we don't even know if he is actually gifted. He might not be. On the other hand, he's not being challenged academically at school.
What would you do? I see a few options, but am open to other ideas:
1. We could sign him up for cogat testing at a local public school to see if he qualifies for the self-contained gifted program in 1at grade. I believe they are only looking for a 95th percentile for that program. Downside would be that he is super shy and has finally made friends at his current school.
2. We could try to push for more challenging work during the school day. I don't know how successful we would be in this, but we could try to brainstorm some ideas.
3. We could just give school some time to see how it works out going forward. After finding out about the small groups, I started adding some work for my son at home, which he enjoys. He is doing beast academy and a workbook on multisyllabic words. He is also reading chapter books and nonfiction books and writing in his notebook for fun.
0
70
Read More
|
|
Re: What exactly counts as prepping?
L Mom
11/04/26 06:44 PM
Nope. Trust the psychologist. I don't personally think it's possible to coach a child to an artificially high score on an individually administered IQ test unless you're teaching the specific tasks in the specific way they are presented on the actual test. I don't see doing logic games and puzzles as being any different than reading and having conversations with your child. Could doing these things improve their scores a small amount? Possibly, but that's due to actual learning.
3
785
Read More
|
|
|
|