I agree with the opinion that Blue Ribbon schools do not mean a definite good fit for your child. We are in a Blue Ribbon school district and we moved here partly for the school's reputation. It did not take long to find out from other parents that the schools focus their teaching material on what is on the state standardized test. The school's goal is to mainstream everyone (at least at the elementary level). Very little, if any attention, is paid to the academically advanced students.
A couple of our friends who have older gifted children ended up either home schooling and/or private school. For private schools: they go visit the school, try to find other families with children in that school (or have tried the school) and talk to them. Sometimes, you can ask the school to see if there are any parents who are willing to talk to you from the parents' point of view. Or even better, talk to some students while you are visiting the school. Students tend to be more frank about their opinions.
Another option that I tried was to post my questions on:
http://www.mamapedia.com/ The advantage is that you can specify an particular school area. Obviously, always take the advice with a grain of salt.
Hope this helps.... and good luck!
