One thing I find myself questioning about that aspiengirls site is the rather wide range of descriptions--"girls may like art, nature, sci-fi, anime, drawing, reading, fashion, animals" (this is from memory, not a direct qote, but I believe those are all mentioned)--this sounds like a list of things that many/most girls find interesting. So, yes, my DD likes some of those things, but it's hard for me to feel convinced by it.