Oh, I think harry potter and percy Jackson are both fluffy. No slam on Harry, more of a slam on AR.

I did want her to read Percy Jackson because there are surprisingly few books in the genre she likes that are first person narration. We went through her books over winter break trying to find some, as we were discussing the differences and why an author would pick a different narration style, and couldn't find any examples.

We have Chrestomanci on the TBR pile. It sounds awesome.