I read so many wonderful acceleration stories, yet I have so many questions. I would have to guess that most other YS kids are like mine and don't get nearly enough even by 1 or 2 grades of acceleration. Some schools make pullouts work, but I wonder how they get around the issues our teacher described. Plus, even "new" subjects seem so basic at grade level.

Yes! I would totally agree with this. DS skipped 1 grade but could easily be skipped again but I don't want to 1) upset other child in that grade 2) make him soo much younger than the others in his public school. I know we need to do something though. He complains about homework because he already learned it in class, etc. His grades are great but he never has to study. It sounds like you found a great fit for your DS, he is very fortunate to have a great program!