Gifted Issues Discussion homepage Forums Learning Environments Public or private

I live and teach in a very low performing district. I get a lot of grief because I do not send my DS to this district. I've heard everything from "you must be a bad teacher if you can't fix things enough to make it okay for your own kid" to very very racist comments that I am afraid of my child associating with certain types of people.
It's all a bunch of baloney. I don't send my kid because they have said they cannot and will not meet his needs. Our ridiculous gate coordinator wanted to skip DS into 2nd grade at 4 1/2... fine(in theory) because that was close to his level. BUT she wanted to hold him there for two years so he could take the standardized tests raising their 2nd grade scores because that's where they are the worst. We are waiting to get into a charter school in our district that has agreed to meet his needs. I'm not opposed to public school but I am opposed to BAD school.

My personal teaching experience shows that the markers for a good school system are: parent involvement, solid discipline plans, high expectations and a low admin cost in comparison to in-class spending. If you spend 10K per child but 4K goes to administration, you will not get the same high quality education. This isn't to say that principals etc, should be underpaid. But you don't need 1 principal, 2 vice-principals, 3 counselors, one school resource officer (read COP!) and 3 other administrators plus office staff for a school of 500 kids... yet that's what my local elementary school has!

Wow! That is a lot of overhead on a lot of non-teaching staff.

You know, the one objection I saw raised about homeschooling that gave me pause was the issue of racism. Though given that race was not remotely why we were removing DS from the school, and given that we live in a lily white area with darn near no one of color in the public schools ( ), I didn't pause too long...

As it turns out, DS sees a lot more racial variety by homeschooling, since it takes us all over the city, and people of many ethnicities homeschool in our area. Ironic! LOL!

There are a far more minority students at my daughter�s urban parochial school than at our local public school. The same is true for my son�s private school if foreign students are figured.