I had a similar experience with my DS. He was in kindergarten when he took the SAGES test and I am not sure why, he scored less in the reasoning part and pretty good in the other two sub-tests. However, this year in 1st grade, we relocated and he joined a different school district in a different state and scored in the 99th percentile in his cogat screener. I am wondering if some of the questions in the SAGES test can be confusing for very young children, compared to tests like COGAT.