Originally Posted by HowlerKarma
Originally Posted by Bostonian
Originally Posted by Wren
After the whole Ivy League admissions topic, I thought this was an interesting book to discuss.

One of the things she cites early is that IQ accounts for only 10% of the reason people are successful in the workplace.

Even if the 10% figure is true, IQ and the academic credentials it helps one attain influence what workplace one joins and in what role. I've read stories about successful people who worked their way up from mail room. I don't see that happening nowadays. At my company, the mail room and cafeteria staff work for sub-contractors.

Exactly.

College is problematic now for a whole host of reasons-- but we are (IMO) a long way from that degree/credentialing process "becoming irrelevant."

NO way would I want my DD to take up the Thiel Fellowship. NO. WAY.

It's a nice idea, but the problem is that the statistics are harshly and emphatically not on the side of the $100,000... and honestly, that 100K is already a memory within four years of a theoretical college diploma for all but a very fortunate few.

But the Thiel fellows are not required to permanently forgo getting a degree, and I'd guess that many of them will go back to school. An advantage of acceleration is that one can take a risk but still have time to get back on the usual track. That said, I am not saying I would encourage taking a Thiel fellowship or equivalent -- it obviously depends on the student.