Butter (DD8)
Thames and Konos C500 Chemistry Set-can't do this with little sister in the house, but when we bust it out...look out! lol!
magnifying glass (from the dollar store)
French English dictionary
acoustic AND electric guitars
all manner of art and drawing supplies (high quality ones)
Legos (primary colors)
oh and a one piece sleep outfit with hood and zipoff booties that strongly resembles the famous rabbit outfit from A Christmas Story. But she loves it and looks cute, heehee

The Diva (DD4y9.5mo)
DS lite (because she doesn't know there's anything fancier, lol)
Crayola coloring book that you add a picture of yourself into
Fancy Nancy fancy wrist ribbons craft
Legos (pink)

We also got Just Dance 2 and Just Dance Kids. Haven't gotten them out yet, but the kids can't wait to try!

I get excited when the library lets me know my books are ready for pickup...