I agree with Grinity above--unless there is some kind of undiagnosed LD, I would say that she prob. just is not used to this level of challenge, and even though she is likely perfectly capable of doing the work, it is a shock after years of not having to try very hard. I am sorry for your dd, I can imagine how difficult it must be for her. But better to face it now than in college with no study skills. As hard as it might be, I personally wouldn't let her go back. Interested to see the outcome, as I have a 4th grade dd as well.