Honestly, I would try the most convenient and cheapest option first, the one with the best education focused on the whole child.
Then from there I would be constantly assessing how things are going for the child, how my relationship with the teacher and with the staff was going, and how the situation was working for my family life.
I have the firm belief that kindergarten should be a time filled with wonderful memory makers for my children. I wanted them to plant marigold seeds, to color, to paste, to cut, to build with blocks, to learn whatever they were interested in.
As long as my kiddos were happy at that age in their classrooms, we were satisfied. The years worth of growth they both did was more social and interpersonal. They both went into kindy having learned the curriculum at least a year in advance.
Make it easy on yourself and reassess the situation as time goes on.
