Thanks everyone for the replies. This option is under consideration, but DH isn't wild about it, not that he's the sole decision-maker. Truthfully, I wasn't terribly impressed with the person I spoke with at the school, but we are keeping an open mind and looking into it further.

While it does appeal to us to have some help or guidance, we are finding that we can also get that from other schools that are totally online. Anyone have feedback on Connections Academy (no school in my state, so it'd be online only)? Or any other virtual schools?

I guess I'm a bit nervous and excited at the same time. I like the accountability to a school that will be responsible for maintaining his records and can let me know if I'm doing something wrong (before I really mess things up), but I'm also really looking forward to doing this at home. I know it'll be a lot work and difficult at times, but I also think it's going to be fun and that DS will begin to enjoy learning again. I'm (a little) afraid that once we tell him we're HSing, but he has to go to school once or twice a week that he'll hold on to the negative attitude he's develop(ed/ing). He's terribly excited at even the prospect that he might be HSed.

We're still looking into everything, so any suggestions/recommendations are appreciated. Thanks again!