After reading all this I don't know what to think!!!!
My daughter started reading early and read the Harry potter books, Narnia and unfortunate events and Nancy Drew in her first grade BLAH, BLAH, BLAH BLAH BLAH! But when they tested her for GT, they said she is ok in English but her math is thru the roof!
In math she scored 99 percentile in COGAT and 99 in nonverbal.
She hates writing and especially essays or even paragraphs make her looking around for escape routes!
Yes, riding bike and catching ball weren't enjoyed either!

Some one said in another post, some thing about school being too easy for their son and any subject that he has to put an effort is the hated subject.
That sure describes her!
Now is my daughter gifted in math or reading?