My DYS dd 11 asked why ALL THE TIME! Charming as it was, I remember it drove me bonkers. She still does it, as in she and I are watching Downton Abbey together, and she can't help herself, but has to ask out loud, "Why is Rose kissing him?!" My husband jokes that her nickname is "why?" And ds 9's nickname is "but...!" We are thinking of getting t-shirts made that say "But why?"