I tend to go over and over these kinds of decisions myself. I think it's because all the options are less than ideal. Some of my school choices have worked out well for the kids, some not. I guess that's life. I've just tried to do the best I could with the information at hand. From what you describe, I would be inclined toward Fancy School. They will ee (a big plus) and even though they lack a GT program, there are lots of activities to occupy your DD. Could you enroll them both in Fancy School?