They said that was completely different.


Well, suuuuuure. Because THAT student is likely to be a drag on meeting AYP benchmarks come NCLB testy-test-test time.

Completely different. Gaaaa... crazy

I have no real advice for you, other than perhaps making a formal request for evaluation under IDEA-- a "complete evaluation, not limited in scope" is the phrase-that-pays there.

If they give you grief, show them Lillie-Felton. He doesn't have to be "failing" to warrant evaluation.

Schrödinger's cat walks into a bar. And doesn't.