As for accommodations, I have mixed feelings. Most kids would do better given a bit more time. I have an issue with kids who are scoring 2000+ without extra time, then they get extra time and score 2300+. If you are already scoring 90th percentile or above, I don't see why you should get more time. However, I know some kids who truly need the accommodation (for valid physical reasons), and I have no issue with that.
Just to clarify, two students with comparable medical reasons are each entitled to appropriate accommodations, even if one is already scoring above the 90th percentile, correct?
I first read your post as indicating the opposite for the already high-scoring student -- that he should not be eligible for accommodation if already scoring 2000+ on SAT, for example.
