Originally Posted by master of none
That's not a comprehension issue as much as a retelling issue.

I have one like that.

It depends very much on the assessment; many of them are poorly designed IMO. We had "remedial" scores on both Fountas and Pinnell and DRA, but using the Reading A to Z benchmarks, far ahead of grade level. The latter test is more specific in what it asks the student to recall/retell, not just "tell me about the book."

DeeDee