Gifted Issues Discussion homepage
Posted By: cee Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/23/14 02:09 PM
Came back from meeting. Present were principal, guidance counselor, K-12 math instructional coordinator, and the teacher for Accelerated 7/8 class. Honors Algebra teacher had a class she could not get out of.

They went over the logistics of his schedule for the next couple of years, if he were to do Honors Integrated Algebra as a 7th grader. One concern they brought up is to make sure my son is okay with the fact that once he is in 8th grade/2015, he will be taking Honors Geometry in the HS building in a class with 9th graders. They made a point of saying they've never had a middle school student go to the high school building for a class. They're totally willing to do it, though.

They got the district's approval to give my son "summer school" to cover all the 8th grade gaps that he needs to understand before starting Algebra. He would have his own certified teacher. The usual schedule is 2 hours a day, 4x week for six weeks. He would be assessed regularly as he goes, and he would retain the option of dropping down to accelerated 7/8 next year. But I doubt he would want to, after studying 8th grade math all summer.

I will talk to my son today with the details I have, to make sure he is on board, and that he knows that in 8th grade he will go to the high school for a geometry class. Fortunately the buildings connect and he can just walk over.

I am really grateful to the district for offering this, but I am a tiny bit nervous, almost like "be careful what you wish for". I hope that he enjoys this accelerated math experience. Have any gifted children in a similar situation wished they didn't do this after starting, or is it always a positive choice?
Posted By: DeeDee Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/23/14 02:44 PM
DS11 is on a similar track, multiply accelerated, and he has always been happy about the acceleration. He's often not been challenged enough, but it's kept things livable.

We are working on a transition/support plan to make work at the high school feasible from a social/emotional and practical point of view.
Posted By: cee Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/23/14 02:49 PM
DeeDee I would love to hear what the plan is to make his HS transition workable on the social emotional levels! That's been one of my concerns that I keep kind of quiet so as not to influence what the school district offers me. I want to hear all options they have and then I decide.

They want me to be aware that in 2015, when he is 12 years old, he would be taking a class in the high school building and that no one else has done it before. So there is probably no guidance curriculum (not the best word) to support younger kids taking HS classes.

Have you had conversations and specific ideas discussed with son's school about social aspects?
Posted By: DeeDee Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/23/14 02:55 PM
Cee, will PM you.
Posted By: cee Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/23/14 03:07 PM
Originally Posted by master of none
As long as he embraces summer school, sounds like a great plan and a wonderfully accommodating school.

Remember you can always go backward. In our school system, about a third of the kids take alg in7th and geom 8th. It doesn't take a high level of giftedness. My bigger concern would be that if your son is very gifted in math, the summer will pique his interest and then the other classes will still be rather slow for him.

At least that's what's happening here! The more you give, the more they want. Danged selfish kids (don't attack me, I'm kidding!)

Funny!

One third of your 7th graders taking Algebra? I think the people that I met with today would fall on the floor if they heard that.

Another good thing to come of this: if my son embraces summer, and does well in Algebra next year, it would encourage more outside of the box thinking, and more readiness to accelerate for my son and any other child coming into their schools.

Posted By: NotSoGifted Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/23/14 03:20 PM
I think our district has 10 to 20% of 7th graders taking Algebra I. And there are always a few 5th graders bussed to the middle school for math, always a few middle school kids bussed to the HS for math, and always at least a couple of 8th/9th graders who ran out of math and take courses at a nearby university.

If they bus him to the HS for math, make sure it is for the honors (or highest level) of that course. You need to be in the highest math track in our district for the bussing thing to happen. This also ensures that the HS kids don't pick on him - other gifted/high achiever kids typically won't make him feel uncomfortable.
Posted By: Nutmeg Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/28/14 04:58 PM
Hi...been following this thread.

My 5th grader will be taking honors algebra next year as a 6th grader... She will also have to head over to the HS in 8th grade after she takes Geometry in 7th (the schools are right next to each other). She is one of the very youngest in her grade (makes the cutoff by a day... plus there are lots of kids with summer birthday that are held back). So she is going to be with kids that will be 2-3 years older than her!

Would love to hear back from others who had a child take algebra in 6th grade!

Thanks.

Posted By: bluemagic Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/28/14 05:24 PM
Sounds like a good plan. Not sure why they have never had a student do this before. Check with him. Worst thing that can happen is he will have to take the 7th/8th grade math next year.

My district was transporting kids to take Geometry to the H.S. (required a bus) for years. And only a few years ago finally go smart and brought the H.S. teacher to the junior high instead.
Posted By: playandlearn Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/28/14 08:22 PM
Things are definitely changing, and districts are also quite different. In our district, only a few years ago there would be few 7th graders taking algebra (probably less than 5%). Right now about 10-15% 7th graders take accelerated algebra. There used to be a few 8th graders who go to HS for math. Now the number of 8th graders taking HS math is large enough that there are HS math classes taught at the middle school. What I heard is that this trend is continuing in the district.
Posted By: RobotMom Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/28/14 08:41 PM
Lots of districts are actually making 8th grade algebra the "norm" and the advanced kids take it in 7th grade. In fact the NCTM (National Council for Teachers of Mathematics) is having a number of conferences this summer about how to gear the math curriculum in middle and elementary school so that all kids are algebra ready by 8th grade. This implies that it is a growing trend in the nation that it will be the normal course of things soon. So, it really shouldn't be too much of a stretch to them allow younger kids to take it.

My DD took algebra at age 9 with 8th graders and since the teacher had an accepting mindset and understood that there could be social issues between her and the other kids in class she was very well taken care of and accepted. In terms of having kids go to high school for classes early, I would just be sure to talk to the teacher of the math class before it starts and ensure that they are aware of the characteristics of gifted kids (other than the obvious one of being really smart).
I would also be skeptical as to whether or not all of extra math in the summer will be needed. You will probably find that he will need much less time than that to fill in the gaps.
Posted By: momtofour Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/29/14 01:11 PM
Originally Posted by Nutmeg
Hi...been following this thread.

My 5th grader will be taking honors algebra next year as a 6th grader... Would love to hear back from others who had a child take algebra in 6th grade!

My ds just is just finishing up Alg and 6th grade. It's worked out just fine. This quarter, he has 100% on quizzes, 97% on tests, and 89% on homework, for an overall grade of just under 97%. It's been the same all year, although his homework grade was better (there are only 4-5 graded homework assignments a quarter, and he managed to leave one in his locker this quarter). He is with gifted 7th graders taking the class, and will be bused to the HS in 8th for first period, and then brought back to the MS. It's not ideal (might interfere with some extracurricular music in the morning, but they are pretty flexible), but I think it will work out. At our school, it's not "normal," but it's not so unusual. A lot actually just depends on the teacher/principal at elementary and whether they're willing to make it happen. Older son is taking Geometry in 8th this year and could probably sleep through Alg II/Trig next year, but when he was at the crucial point, we had a principal who didn't believe in acceleration (because of the way math acceleration works, they're usually only willing to do extra in certain years when it won't result in a 'double' skip.

Younger ds was bussed to MS last year and it was great-I think that part of the reason he was chosen as a peer mediator and peer guide for other students this year was because the transition to MS was relaxed and comfortable for him. In HS, he can take Pre-Calc, BC Calc, Calc III, AP Stats, AP Computer Science, and frankly, if he suddenly decided he wants to take no math his senior year because he's going to be a music major, I'm fine with that too.

I would have had NO problem pulling him back to pre-Alg if I thought he was struggling and I don't think anyone would have cared. The other 6th grade kids are very supportive when it (rarely) comes up and the 7th graders are welcoming and friendly. Add in the 8th graders he knows because of his brother and it's great that he seems to know everyone in a very large school!

Good luck to your daughter - my son seems to enjoy class more the closer it is to his level.

Posted By: knute974 Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/29/14 02:16 PM
It is standard here for gt/honors track to have Algebra in 7th and Geometry in 8th. Our local high school is hostile to kids accelerating more than this. You may want to check out how this would work with the high school that you want your child to attend.

Our middle school was willing to do an independent study version of Algebra II for DD. When we spoke to the high school which is an IB school, they said that she "wouldn't fit in the IB schedule" if she did this. It really turned me off to the school. DD still wants to be there for their music program so she is more willing to compromise than I am.

I have a friend who ended up taking her daughter to another high school for Algebra II in 8th grade. They made it work but the schedule was not ideal. The high school was on a block schedule so classes met every other day for two hours. The middle school had her scheduled for electives at those times that she attended on the days that she did not go to the high school.

I guess the message is that it can work but you need to make sure that the high school has bought into the plan.
Posted By: cee Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/29/14 02:48 PM
Several of you mentioned there was busing from Middle to High School for a math class. Was your child allowed to leave early from prior period, and arrive late for the following one? Was there a lot of missed class time in those before and after classes?
Posted By: NotSoGifted Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/29/14 03:02 PM
In our district, they schedule some math classes first period. So elementary starts at 9am, MS at 8 am, HS at 7:30am. If kid is in elementary, just take the MS bus and take a 1st period math class. In MS, take the HS bus. The only "special transportation" needed is to get the kid back to MS or elementary. In our district, the schools aren't more than a few miles apart, so that is not a big deal. Because of the staggered start times of the elementary, MS and HS, the kids miss little, if any, class time.
Posted By: Nutmeg Re: Had meeting re: Algebra in grade 7 - 05/29/14 04:38 PM
thank for the feedback momtofour... likewise, it is not "normal" in our district to take algebra in 6th but not entirely unusual. There will be 2 others from 6th grade with her (out of about 350 kids), and they will be placed with the 7th graders taking algebra. She will take Honors Geometry in 7th at the MS, then for 8th head over to the HS... luckily the MS and HS are right next to each other so she will just have to walk over with the other 2 kids (they are chaperoned).

Glad it has been a good experience for your child. Hoping my dd will not be shocked to be suddenly challenged in math class!

© Gifted Issues Discussion Forum