DD9 composed a piece of music that won an award. She impresses with her guitar play even though it's very much an off-and-on hobby. And she was recently selected to join her school chorus. I still wouldn't call any of her skills in any one area of music beyond "basic," but comparing with what's normal for 9, she's well ahead. So although she looks nothing like a prodigy (mostly because she's not willing to put in the hours, and we're not willing to compel her to), she definitely has talent.
The best term to describe our DD is "globally gifted," because she does a lot of things, and everything she decides to do, she does well.
