I would disagree with the assertion that because she is not adequately prepared for advanced math in high school, she is unable to attend an elite college and does not have the intelligence to succeed in competitive programs. the article says nothing about the quality of the education she received prior to enrollment in the suburban high school. A poor quality foundation in early math instruction is extremely difficult to overcome later.
Similarly, the SATs remain a barrier for some highly intelligent students from impoverished backgrounds for reasons that no one has been able to parse out completely.
As the mom of a profoundly gifted African American male, and the wife of am African American who grew up in extreme poverty, I know first hand the obstacles to success that must be overcome in this country if you are not born into privilege. While differences in ability and talent and intelligence clearly exist, there is also a significant opportunity gap in this country that holds back many highly intelligent and driven people, and advantages other people who are not as intelligent or driven.
Last edited by mom of 1; 11/23/11 10:38 AM.
