Gifted Issues Discussion homepage
Posted By: Bostonian Michelle Obama was in a gifted program - 05/16/14 08:08 PM
This may be a good anecdote to mention when gifted programs are criticized as "elitist".

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/16/us/a-decision-that-helped-shape-a-first-lady.html
A Decision That Helped Shape Michelle Obama
By SHERYL GAY STOLBERG
New York Times
MAY 15, 2014

Quote
One of her kindergarten classmates, Dr. Theodore Ford, described their class this way in a 2012 article in The Chicago Sun-Times: “There were five little white faces and 23 shades of brown faces and one Middle Eastern face, a subtle shade darker than that of the Jewish kid to his right in our class photo.”

The school appears to have had more resources than most. In the sixth grade, Mrs. Obama was selected to participate in its gifted program, which allowed her to take French, and to study biology at the local community college, according to Ms. Mundy’s book. She graduated as its salutatorian.

But it was the creation of Chicago’s first public high school for high achievers — the Whitney M. Young Magnet High School — that really changed the trajectory of Mrs. Obama’s life, by getting her out of her neighborhood and giving her exposure for the first time to an educational environment that was truly diverse.

...

“So at 6 a.m. every morning, I had to get on a city bus and ride for an hour, sometimes more, just to get to school,” Mrs. Obama told a group of Washington high school students last year.

One of Mrs. Obama’s close friends and classmates was Santita Jackson, daughter of the Rev. Jesse Jackson. “It was a school of high expectations,” Mr. Jackson said in an interview, in which he called Mrs. Obama “an odds-buster and a dream-maker” who “was always driven to aim high.”

Mrs. Obama credits Whitney Young with setting her on a path to Princeton University and Harvard Law School. Charles J. Ogletree Jr., her law professor at Harvard, remembers her work with the black law students association there.

Yeah, we have to find a way to have an honest dialogue so that we can talk about the needs of gifted students, without offending anyone who might not be firmly in that category depending on the experts doing the determinations at the time.

It is really hard to get people to understand that any society might be failing the brightest, most sensitive minds, because so many other factors figure into society. And, if a gifted person is not able to speak up and if no one speaks for them, then we have missed opportunities.

I think it is possible that gifted people might be happiest in a merit based environment. When you enter a truly merit based environment, everyone is represented, in fact you spend your initial period together sizing each other up trying to figure out what you have in common. It might just be that IQ does not have a direct correlation to any one 'profile.' Gifted people are born all over the globe.
Posted By: indigo Re: Michelle Obama was in a gifted program - 05/21/14 02:16 PM
Some may say that having benefitted from gifted education herself as a child, and taking note that the article expresses that the opportunity for gifted education changed the course of her life, our First Lady could be expected to be a strong and outspoken proponent for gifted education today.

Unfortunately she has not. frown
© Gifted Issues Discussion Forum