Well, not exactly the same situation as there is no dysgraphia accommodations/modifications and it is only two grades rather than three. For what it is worth, DS is enrolled in 8th grade GT Geometry as a 6th grader with bad handwriting and there have been no issues either academically or socially. His teacher even volunteered a couple of months ago that it was absolutely the correct placement as DS fits in with the other kids in every way, including socially.