I think what is a problem is not "allowing" children to have more choice. Really, if your kid is fine with it - no problem. My older kid probably wouldn't be fine with it. He's only in second but has been reading non-picture high level chapter books for two years now. I just don't think kids should unecessarily have their choices limited like that. It frustrates them and honestly it makes them hate reading. Kids should be permitted read books, period. That is how it was in my day and while I do not endorse much of my day I endorse that. No one FORCED me to read "only" picture books or "only" chapter books or "only" books about horses or "only" books about whatever. I got to read what I wanted to read.
Agreed: A book which the teacher uses to work with the students ought not to limit students' choice for other reading. There should be no ceiling for the student choices in reading level. Student choice is important to
developing internal locus of control and the student taking ownership of their education.
