OTOH both scores indicate some type of giftedness so it wouldn't hurt to try and figure out how to write a letter and appeal the group testing using the scores especially if you think she needs to be in the program. Have you tried to look for your districts legal policy? I was surprised at how much was there but I kind of had to hunt around on our district website to find it. There's probably at least a director of advanced services to call and talk to about the requirements/appeals.