Oh, and one other caveat about using that 9-12 list in particular?
Be aware that it contains pretty much the entirety of the reading selections for AP English Literature, so if you want to have those selections be NOVEL for a gifted HS student, you might want to choose carefully.
Over the course of DD's three years of honors high school English, she's read at least eight of those already as mandatory literature for class.
(I've deliberately held off on some things like Fitzgerald and Hawthorne so that they will be novel when she sees them in class.)
HTH.
