Gifted Bulletin Board

Welcome to the Gifted Issues Discussion Forum.

We invite you to share your experiences and to post information about advocacy, research and other gifted education issues on this free public discussion forum.
CLICK HERE to Log In. Click here for the Board Rules.

Links
DITD Logo

Learn about the Davidson Academyís online campus for profoundly gifted students living anywhere in the U.S.

The Davidson Institute for Talent Development is a national nonprofit dedicated to supporting profoundly gifted students through the following programs:

  • Davidson Fellows Scholarship
  • Davidson Young Scholars
  • Davidson Academy
  • THINK Summer Institute
  • DITD FaceBook   DITD Twitter   DITD YouTube
    The Davidson Institute is on Facebook, Twitter and YouTube!

    How gifted-friendly is
    your state?

    Subscribe to the Davidson Institute's eNews-Update

    Who's Online
    0 registered (), 0 Guests and 313 Spiders online.
    Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
    Newest Members
    Paul Kevin, salubrious, Lorens, Devaki, kitiye
    10807 Registered Users
    August
    Su M Tu W Th F Sa
    1
    2 3 4 5 6 7 8
    9 10 11 12 13 14 15
    16 17 18 19 20 21 22
    23 24 25 26 27 28 29
    30 31
    Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
    Topic Options
    #247190 - 05/21/20 09:55 AM College Placement Specialist?
    Pemberley Offline
    Member

    Registered: 08/07/11
    Posts: 734
    Has anyone hired a private college placement specialist to aid their 2e child?

    I recently attended a webinar hosted by a local sped attorney on the topic of transition planning. His guest was a ďTransition SpecialistĒ and it got me thinking. Having someone who is familiar with navigating the process might prove very helpful.

    So far Iíve been thinking in 4 ways -

    First to look at a college like Landmark in Vermont which is 100% dedicated to students with special needs. (It started focusing on language based learning disabilities but now also serves students with ADHD and Autism as well.) They require a neuropsych or psycho ed eval with the student application and all supports are included in their rather hefty tuition. I donít know how many other dedicated colleges like this exist or if they would be able to meet DDís gifted needs. Hoping a placement specialist might know of others,

    Second to look at starting at a community college so she can adjust to the college experience before heading off on her own. (DD completed a grade acceleration so will finish HS at a young age. We might be able to postpone until her 17th birthday but not by much.) Her math disability is tough to overcome so I thought about maybe completing math requirements this way and having them transfer in. She also has significant processing issues and relies heavily on assistive technology so large chaotic environments can be tough for her. Her current school teaches everything 1-1 so is perfect for her but she will have to learn to adapt to a regular classroom setting. Our local CC has an expensive special transition program usually paid by local school districts. A friendís daughter made the mistake of accepting her diploma so she wasnít eligible for district payment, Again thinking a placement specialist should be able to guide us so we donít make a similar mistake.

    Third looking for colleges that have specialized embedded programs to meet the needs of sped students. Iíve heard of these programs but feel a bit overwhelmed trying to determine which might be right for DD or even how to find them. Iím concerned that most of these programs may be geared towards students on the spectrum (which DD is not). Her executive functioning and social skills are strong - we would need a program thatís appropriate for her rather than for generic special needs students.

    Fourth everyone tells me over and over that all colleges will offer accommodations as long as DD advocates for herself. I donít feel itís a good idea to drop her in on her own without appropriate scaffolding though. Again Iím hoping a transition or college placement specialist who has a background in special needs would help navigate the process so she can be set up for success.

    So has anyone used someone like this? I realize the simple thing would be to approach the woman from the webinar (sheís local) but I hate going in blind. I donít even know what to google to learn more about this. I went to her website and there was no mention of costs, etc. Iím also wondering how hard it would be to find someone well versed in 2e rather than just special needs placement. I obviously donít want to be sold a service that isnít right for us.

    If anyone has any experience, info or BTDT advice I would love to hear from you.

    TIA

    Top
    #247191 - 05/21/20 11:08 AM Re: College Placement Specialist? [Re: Pemberley]
    aeh Offline
    Member

    Registered: 04/26/14
    Posts: 3638
    Off the top of my head, I would consider looking at Dean College in MA. They have the Arch program, which is as much like K-12 inclusive special education for true college-level content as I have seen, without being a special ed school.
    https://www.dean.edu/support-success/stu...ning-community/

    Extra cost for the program, of course, but those of whom I know who have sent children or attended themselves report that it was worth it. Individual and group support, and targets SLDs, mostly (must be at least average cognitively).

    "Ideal Arch candidates are students who have a discrepancy between measured intelligence and achievement that is directly related to their diagnosed disability."

    Also, as you say, every post-secondary institution that takes federal funds is required to provide disabilities accommodations. Even the community college has a disability services office. What that looks like, of course, is highly variable. So yes, if she has a specific field of study in mind, or other college characteristics (size, urban/rural, region, etc.), it may be helpful to find a college consultant with 2e experience. You have a singularity among singularities, so I would expect a perfect fit will be a challenge, (even at the consultant level) but the right resource may be able to connect you to other right resources with the information you need. I think the place to start would probably be the local person, mainly to help you compile a list of questions you should be asking of disability service offices.

    Top
    #247192 - 05/21/20 10:58 PM Re: College Placement Specialist? [Re: Pemberley]
    MumOfThree Offline
    Member

    Registered: 04/07/11
    Posts: 1628
    Loc: Australia
    Originally Posted By: Pemberley

    Fourth everyone tells me over and over that all colleges will offer accommodations as long as DD advocates for herself. I donít feel itís a good idea to drop her in on her own without appropriate scaffolding though. Again Iím hoping a transition or college placement specialist who has a background in special needs would help navigate the process so she can be set up for success.


    I am not in the US, so I can't speak to the US colleges. But where I am, I was repeatedly told that universities are so much better than schools at accommodations, it would be easier once she actually got there... I believed this to an extent. I trusted we would not have to work quite so hard. But I certainly expected to need to advocate carefully and was concerned about our child suddenly having to do it all on their own, when we'd fought all the battles at school.

    I helped her fill out the online form to start the application process (ie "Oh that box means they want a copy of this report"). And I went to her first meeting as a support person and let her run it. I did add a few comments with background information once or twice (maybe she didn't recognise a term for a support she did use at highschool, etc). But mostly I sat back and tried not to fall of my chair in shock.

    EVERYTHING she had had at school, without a single question. They checked she had appropriate professional reports to support those requests and that was it, TICK! And then... "OH, what about adaptive formatting? How would you like your tests and exams laid out? Do you want a special font? Do you need X? Y? Z? What if I set up a meeting with a member of our formatting team? You really should meet them at least once. And we can do this, and we can do that..."

    It really makes no sense at all to me, that supports we had to fight tooth and nail for, let alone things that there is NO WAY we could have gotten for the little girl whose giftedness was utterly overwhelmed by her disabilities... are suddenly falling from the sky only AFTER she's reached the point that she doesn't need most of them. Things I had never heard of, supports I had never imagined... That we didn't ask for.

    "Are you really sure you just need extra time and typing? You can come back and ask for other things if you have any problems!!"... It is so-freaking-hard to get extra time and typing provisions for highschool... and uni is worried it's not enough and really they should be doing all this extra great stuff that they know how to do... It's surreal.

    More than once I have had professionals comment that kids that were as behind as she was don't catch up, they just get further and further behind. She caught up, then she got ahead. That's because she's gifted, not just LD, it's also because she worked so hard, and so did I, with her and for her. WHY is it so hard at school and so easy at uni?

    Top
    #247193 - 05/22/20 08:33 AM Re: College Placement Specialist? [Re: MumOfThree]
    aeh Offline
    Member

    Registered: 04/26/14
    Posts: 3638
    Why? Well in the USA, it's likely because unis want your tuition dollars, so once admitted, they have more of an investment in retention of a student. Public K-12 schools get a certain amount of money per student, and a certain additional amount per special education student (nothing additional for 504 accommodation students), regardless of the level of service offered. Resources are zero-sum. More service for this student means less available for the next student. And you pay for all of those assistive tech licenses. This is also why certain supports are sometimes more available in high needs schools than in moderate need schools: as with free/reduced lunch, once your population exceeds a certain percentage of qualifying students, there are provisions for declaring the whole school qualifying, and subsidizing across the board. Similarly for Title I reading/mathematics academic support for at-risk learners. Or, for licenses, it becomes more cost-effective to purchase an unlimited site license than per-student or per-classroom.

    Less cynically, it's also because basic skills are not the focus of post-secondary education, and the most commonly restricted accommodations generally bridge basic skills gaps. Ironically, it also reflects litigation history, where families have felt that accommodating too early was depriving their children of opportunities for skill remediation, resulting in institutional reluctance to offer those types of accommodations. (There is, of course, legitimacy to both sides of this argument.)

    This question is also why our particular public school decided years ago to make certain accommodations that are often specialized in other schools universal in ours. Our state-wide mandated testing is starting to catch up to that a little bit, and also has added a much wider range of accommodations available without proof of disability than in the past.

    But it is still quite variable across universities, since the federal regulations leave implementation very much in the hands of schools.

    Also, remember that the age of the student is irrelevant--once they are enrolled in a college/university, you as the parent have no rights whatsoever to access their records or communicate with the school regarding their situation, unless your child expressly gives you written permission. It doesn't matter if the student isn't old enough to drive, vote, or sign a legal document (ironically, since how can they legally consent to you viewing their records?)--or have their own iCloud account, for that matter. So make sure you get all that out of the way for written communications, or be present for all conversations the school has with your child.

    Top
    #247194 - 05/23/20 01:55 AM Re: College Placement Specialist? [Re: Pemberley]
    puffin Offline
    Member

    Registered: 12/11/12
    Posts: 2035
    But outside the US the universities are state funded in much the same way as schools and providing extra services cuts into their finances.

    Top
    #247195 - 05/23/20 04:09 AM Re: College Placement Specialist? [Re: Pemberley]
    Wren Offline
    Member

    Registered: 01/14/08
    Posts: 1544
    I do not have a child with special needs, but when I was touring schools in NYC, there was one that was known to deal with all kinds of needs. Special technology, one on one assistants. I do not know what high schools deal with this, but this one particular public school was tailored for special needs kids. It was a mixed school. So most kids did not have special needs. And the classrooms with kids with special needs were a max of 10 kids.

    Top
    #247198 - 05/23/20 07:58 PM Re: College Placement Specialist? [Re: aeh]
    MumOfThree Offline
    Member

    Registered: 04/07/11
    Posts: 1628
    Loc: Australia
    AEH Our school vs. university models are not like the US. Although university is becoming more so, in particularly with regard to our universities' increasing dependence on high fee paying overseas students.

    We have far higher rates of children attending private schooling than I believe is the case in the US (about 30%) but our universities are almost entirely public, there are fees, but it is common to defer fee payment via a government loan which is indexed but interest free, and repaid via taxes only when the student's income is above a certain threshold (and repayment rate is variable based on income: 1% of your income once you are earning over $46k, moving up to 10% of income once you are earning $135k or above). Overseas student fees are completely different.

    My child who has moved from a private high school to arguably the most prestigious university in the country will pay her own uni fees retrospectively, but it should not be financially crippling to do so. And those fees are, from memory, less than half what we were paying p/a for her schooling last year, possibly about a third. I feel like I looked at them when she signed the paper work and declared that her whole BSc degree would cost her what her last year of school cost us.

    Also it's far less common to move away to university here. The vast majority of students go to their local institutions. There are boarding colleges, which are used by overseas, rural or interstate students. They are not, from what I understand, actually owned by the universities but are private establishments placed near universities. Also many such students just move into share houses, stay with family, etc. So universities are not set up around directly profiting from boarding.

    Our experience of schooling here is that students with significant obvious disabilities are more likely to be well served in the public school system. Where as 2e children will have somewhat more chance of support at the most expensive private schools, who will put resources into helping every child achieve the results they build their reputations on (to justify their fees). Some private schools also do well with children with more obvious "traditional" disabilities, but others you would not be surprised to never see such a student. Generally private schools pay their teachers more, have better staff:student ratios, teachers have more non contact hours for planning and marking, and there is more chance the school will provide special ed services to a child who is not failing. The public system will not provide any supports to a child who is passing, just because they are performing woefully below potential. Also, if you have a child who needs keyboarding during primary years, there is a far higher likelihood of device use being common and/or supported at a private school. This is changing, with ipads at least becoming common (or even required) at public schools in some areas during primary years. But certainly 6 years ago when we moved one of our children to private school for yr4 the need for laptop use was a factor, sending a laptop to her public school would have been very problematic.

    I have a friend with cerebral palsy who is a lecturer in the law department of one of the three major uni's where I grew up (two of which teach law). My take after talking to her recently, and from dealing with schools, is that universities are much more aware of their legal responsibilities with regard to student protections under disability law. Or, conversely that the majority of parents and school teachers have little to no idea of how our disability laws relate to education, but universities do...

    I think there is a massive disconnect between what our laws say (somewhat vaguely) and what schools consider themselves to be required to do. I am genuinely of the belief that most teachers and school leadership are unaware of what the legal requirements actually are. I had no idea until very recently.

    Top
    #247199 - 05/23/20 08:03 PM Re: College Placement Specialist? [Re: MumOfThree]
    MumOfThree Offline
    Member

    Registered: 04/07/11
    Posts: 1628
    Loc: Australia
    Also, things like allowing typing or extra time require almost no cost for a school to allow, they just seem morally opposed (the device would have to be provided by the parents/student whether it was school or university). Even providing different fonts or differently formatted exams are fairly low cost offerings. These things are not at all in the same cost ball park as a full time aide or a scribe...

    It really does feel like schools consider things like extra time, typing, etc to be "cheating" or "trying to get away with something" and the universities consider these things to be reasonable accommodations so that one can access the curriculum equally.

    Top
    #247201 - 05/24/20 05:19 PM Re: College Placement Specialist? [Re: MumOfThree]
    aeh Offline
    Member

    Registered: 04/26/14
    Posts: 3638
    I hear you...part of it I think may reflect the same forces behind the phenomenon of grade school textbooks always being about 20 years behind...a lot of K-12 institutions don't appear to have absorbed the reality that the post-secondary world uses (assistive) technology as a matter of course. It's not even an accommodation. And flipped and online classrooms, with their online, remote-administered assessments, typically allow a good two-hour window to complete an assessment that could be finished in half an hour by a B student. Since they're remote, they almost always allow open notes and calculators as a matter of course. (They do have checks built in...you usually can't go to another site mid-test; if you do, the test will kick you out and consider the assessment done.) And they design them with internal checks for irregularities. Or to emphasize more applications and problem solving, and less rote fact-spewing.

    Perhaps if all K-12 education also emphasized application and problem-solving over rote fact-spewing they would be more comfortable with accommodations...

    Top
    #247202 - 05/24/20 06:06 PM Re: College Placement Specialist? [Re: MumOfThree]
    Eagle Mum Offline
    Member

    Registered: 02/24/20
    Posts: 52
    Loc: Australia
    Originally Posted By: MumOfThree

    It really does feel like schools consider things like extra time, typing, etc to be "cheating" or "trying to get away with something" and the universities consider these things to be reasonable accommodations so that one can access the curriculum equally.


    I suspect this does have some impact on the issue of extra time. Rightly or wrongly, the goal in secondary school, for many students in this country, is to maximise their ATAR score to successfully compete for places in highly sought courses at Uni. Many students attend coaching colleges to help achieve this goal. The selective school entrance exam was extremely fast paced such that students who attended coaching colleges were advantaged mainly by the time management skills they picked up by doing a practice exam every week whereas DS who has never attended a coaching college and has outperformed selective school students at the Maths Olympiad, did not finish the SS exam. He just managed to finish the HSC maths exam last year without a second to spare for checking his answers (he thought he had been able to answer every question but his score of 98 would suggest he made at least one or two silly mistakes). Thus extra time for exams would be carefully scrutinised at primary & secondary school level. Once the student is at Uni, the goal for the individual is to complete their degree, which is not a competitive process.

    Top
    Page 1 of 2 1 2 >


    Moderator:  M-Moderator 
    Recent Posts
    Does anyone have experience of this program?
    by indigo
    Yesterday at 07:11 AM
    Career/taking control of my life at 26
    by Eagle Mum
    08/08/20 03:49 PM
    Aging
    by aeh
    08/02/20 08:46 AM
    Equity for 2e students / Neurodiversity-Disab
    ility

    by indigo
    08/02/20 07:23 AM
    How bad is the social aspect of grade skipping?
    by Eagle Mum
    08/01/20 09:47 PM
    Davidson Institute Twitter