Gifted Bulletin Board

Welcome to the Gifted Issues Discussion Forum.

We invite you to share your experiences and to post information about advocacy, research and other gifted education issues on this free public discussion forum.
CLICK HERE to Log In. Click here for the Board Rules.

Links


Learn about Davidson Academy Online - for profoundly gifted students living anywhere in the U.S. & Canada.

The Davidson Institute is a national nonprofit dedicated to supporting profoundly gifted students through the following programs:

  • Fellows Scholarship
  • Young Scholars
  • Davidson Academy
  • THINK Summer Institute

  • Subscribe to the Davidson Institute's eNews-Update Newsletter >

    Free Gifted Resources & Guides >

    Who's Online Now
    0 members (), 196 guests, and 25 robots.
    Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
    Newest Members
    streble, DeliciousPizza, prominentdigitiz, parentologyco, Smartlady60
    11,413 Registered Users
    March
    S M T W T F S
    1 2
    3 4 5 6 7 8 9
    10 11 12 13 14 15 16
    17 18 19 20 21 22 23
    24 25 26 27 28 29 30
    31
    Previous Thread
    Next Thread
    Print Thread
    Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
    #187468 04/08/14 06:51 AM
    Joined: Aug 2010
    Posts: 3,428
    U
    Member
    OP Offline
    Member
    U
    Joined: Aug 2010
    Posts: 3,428
    If you want a glimpse into the thinking of the teacher who doesn't want your child reading anything above grade level, here you go.

    http://www.nais.org/Magazines-Newsl...Slow-and-Steady-Still-Wins-the-Race.aspx

    ultramarina #187476 04/08/14 07:17 AM
    Joined: Jul 2011
    Posts: 2,007
    Member
    Offline
    Member
    Joined: Jul 2011
    Posts: 2,007
    Originally Posted by ultramarina
    If you want a glimpse into the thinking of the teacher who doesn't want your child reading anything above grade level, here you go.

    http://www.nais.org/Magazines-Newsl...Slow-and-Steady-Still-Wins-the-Race.aspx

    From the article:

    "The symptoms of the Harry Potter Effect persist well past kindergarten and first grade. They appear even more severe as these early readers seem to plateau in their growth just as their peers begin to catch up. Children suffering from the Harry Potter Effect feel these symptoms most acutely as they sense their status as the “best” is being threatened. Children whose self-esteem is bonded so tightly with their image as being “smart”—which is consistently the adjective parents and schools use to describe children who read at a young age—can experience painful resentment as they see more and more of their peers placed in the advanced reading group and thrive there. These first graders who had proudly shared with anyone who would listen that they were reading Harry Potter are at risk of becoming fourth graders who must be incentivized in order to read anything at all."

    This gets into what I was trying to articulate with respect to developmental arc.

    Some kids are like what this teacher sees.

    Some are not.

    So, this thinking is appropriate in some situations and not in others.

    master of none #187479 04/08/14 07:34 AM
    Joined: Jul 2011
    Posts: 2,007
    Member
    Offline
    Member
    Joined: Jul 2011
    Posts: 2,007
    Originally Posted by master of none
    Second, it drives me nuts when teachers cheapen reading with external rewards. I made a conscious effort to undermine this with my kids in order to keep it intrinsically rewarding.

    Almost all of my reading is based on external rewards, so it's certainly consistent with the working world.

    master of none #187481 04/08/14 07:40 AM
    Joined: Feb 2009
    Posts: 604
    Member
    Offline
    Member
    Joined: Feb 2009
    Posts: 604
    Originally Posted by master of none
    Second, it drives me nuts when teachers cheapen reading with external rewards. I made a conscious effort to undermine this with my kids in order to keep it intrinsically rewarding.

    I agree - at DD6's school they make such a big deal out of earning AR points to get all of these silly certificates that it turns a lot of kids off form reading. The only books in the library are books that have AR tests associated with them! Granted, most books now have AR tests with them, but why should a child have to take a test on every library book they read? Why can't they just read because they think it is an interesting book? I know some of DD's friends hate reading already in 1st grade because of the tests and the thought of not getting enough points to get the next reward before everyone else does.

    ultramarina #187485 04/08/14 07:53 AM
    Joined: Aug 2010
    Posts: 3,428
    U
    Member
    OP Offline
    Member
    U
    Joined: Aug 2010
    Posts: 3,428
    " These first graders who had proudly shared with anyone who would listen that they were reading Harry Potter are at risk of becoming fourth graders who must be incentivized in order to read anything at all."

    I don't know any kids like this. Does anyone else? A child who read HP or similar in first grade and then became a nonreader in 4th?

    What really aggravated me (well, among other things) was her theory that kids who learn to read later become better readers than those who independently learn to read early. There is no evidence for this. Her private school background is probably completely deluding her here, in the sense that sure, there are indeed bright kids (what's the average IQ at her school--115, 120?) who read late and then catch up very well. But much of the time, the child who is struggling with reading in second grade is a child who is going to continue to struggle. Early problems with reading predict future problems for most of the population, and early success with reading, especially untaught, predicts future success. It's not a big mystery. This is established. As a literacy specialist or whatever, she really ought to know this.

    ultramarina #187486 04/08/14 07:56 AM
    Joined: Aug 2010
    Posts: 3,428
    U
    Member
    OP Offline
    Member
    U
    Joined: Aug 2010
    Posts: 3,428
    Respectfully, psychland, I really disagree. That is, I agree with this:

    Quote
    When you have to work to decode text your comprehension of it is not great. It does not matter how bright you are you are still missing things.

    Yes. When my kindergartener reads The Phoenix and the Carpet, he is missing things that his older sister does not miss.

    But I completely disagree with this:

    Quote
    When you read a book for fun you should be able to decode all the words (with the possible exception of one of two, in the book NOT per page) and understand all of the nuances of the language used. If you can't do that you probably should not read it.

    Very, very strongly disagree. I feel sad just thinking about that, actually. In the BOOK? So DD8 should have been able to decode every word in every Harry Potter book before I "allowed" her to read them? You are going to forbid your daughter to read them till she can decode every single word (but one or two) in the 700+ page tomes in the later books. How would you even know? Heck, there may be a few words in those books that *I* did not know.

    ultramarina #187487 04/08/14 07:56 AM
    Joined: Jul 2013
    Posts: 222
    C
    Member
    Offline
    Member
    C
    Joined: Jul 2013
    Posts: 222
    I don't have a problem with it at an earlier age in an effort to improve reading ability. Of course, if a teacher want to limit a child from expanding their reading ability, there is no point. This year when homeschooling my DD8, we made her read longer chapter books. Initially, she took forever to read her one chapter for the day. She complained like crazy. After a few weeks, she was reading in 1/10 of the time from when we started. After a couple months, she started to actually like reading.

    ultramarina #187488 04/08/14 08:02 AM
    Joined: Oct 2011
    Posts: 2,856
    Member
    Offline
    Member
    Joined: Oct 2011
    Posts: 2,856
    1) Reading comprehension as a skill and reading comprehension as evaluated by early elementary school teachers are not the same thing.

    2) "Sarah" is spending most of her reading time reading alone, whereas "Aaron" is reading with adults. One is interacting with educated people and learning to analyze text, the other is not. Should we really be surprised that the one doesn't learn how to analyze?

    I think this teacher has made a valid observation, but then she says, "Here is what I think is happening," and her hypothesis is wrong.

    Also, I didn't get the impression that her observations extend past 4th grade. I think she might be surprised if she were to look at Sarah and Aaron in 10th grade.

    And this part was just plain hilarious:
    Quote
    Children who begin to read independently at an older age approach the reading process more systematically and with more maturity. These students employ a variety of comprehension tools such as accessing background knowledge and drawing on a much larger bank of vocabulary.

    Errr... late readers have larger vocabularies? In what parallel universe?

    ultramarina #187489 04/08/14 08:04 AM
    Joined: Oct 2011
    Posts: 2,856
    Member
    Offline
    Member
    Joined: Oct 2011
    Posts: 2,856
    Originally Posted by ultramarina
    " These first graders who had proudly shared with anyone who would listen that they were reading Harry Potter are at risk of becoming fourth graders who must be incentivized in order to read anything at all."

    I don't know any kids like this. Does anyone else? A child who read HP or similar in first grade and then became a nonreader in 4th?

    My DD is in 4th, and read HP in 1st. A couple of months ago she was outraged that DW and I had visited a new second-hand bookstore without her.

    ultramarina #187490 04/08/14 08:05 AM
    Joined: Jul 2011
    Posts: 2,007
    Member
    Offline
    Member
    Joined: Jul 2011
    Posts: 2,007
    Originally Posted by ultramarina
    " These first graders who had proudly shared with anyone who would listen that they were reading Harry Potter are at risk of becoming fourth graders who must be incentivized in order to read anything at all."

    I don't know any kids like this. Does anyone else? A child who read HP or similar in first grade and then became a nonreader in 4th?

    This relates to the conversation over in the Tiger Parenting thread hyper-competition thread.

    Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

    Moderated by  M-Moderator 

    Link Copied to Clipboard
    Recent Posts
    Testing with accommodations
    by aeh - 03/27/24 01:58 PM
    Quotations that resonate with gifted people
    by indigo - 03/27/24 12:38 PM
    New, and you'd think I'd have a clue...
    by astronomama - 03/24/24 06:01 AM
    For those interested in astronomy, eclipses...
    by indigo - 03/23/24 06:11 PM
    Son 2e, wide discrepancy between CogAT-Terranova
    by astronomama - 03/23/24 07:21 AM
    Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5